Myth-Busting the Publishing Industry

It seems like there’s a lot of name-calling going on in the publishing industry today. Publishers, agents, and self-publishing enthusiasts are at odds, touting the benefits of their own services while discounting the others. Who should writers trust when seeking publication? The answer is about as complicated as the publishing industry itself. There is no right way to be published, but certain methods work better for various authors and each path towards publication has its own advantages and disadvantages. It’s time to put some nasty rumors about publishing houses, agents, and self-publishing to rest.

Myth #1: Publishers rip off authors

Many advocates of self-publishing believe that publishing houses are money-hungry and disconnected from authors and readers. J. A. Konrath, a fiction writer whose books have been in the Kindle Top 100 bestselling e-books, claims that publishers “screw authors” by denying them the royalties they deserve, assuming too much control over their work, and inadequately editing, marketing, publicizing their books. Although Konrath has had experience with publishing houses (Hyperion published his Jack Daniels thriller series), his low opinion of publishers is biased. Unlike many self-published authors, Konrath has earned hundreds of thousands of dollars from selling his own books. He has an already-established following of readers, many of whom discovered him when his Jack Daniels series was published. Konrath also hires out the editing and designing of his books to freelancers. Many writers do not have the resources and experience that Konrath does.

Even the most successful don’t; after making millions by self-publishing, Amazon superstar Amanda Hocking recently signed a book deal with St. Martin’s Press. While self-publishing can and does allow some authors to earn more than those who work with publishers, writers who publish traditionally get the benefit of working with professional editors, designers, and marketing experts who have experience handling both the creative and financial aspects of producing books. Publishers rely on authors, and many are dedicated to treating writers well, says Jeremy Greenfield, editorial director of Digital Book World.


Myth #2: Agents aren’t relevant

With the popularity of self-publishing increasing exponentially, many people wonder if literary agents will become extinct. Some authors complain that literary agents don’t return their calls or, more importantly, don’t sell their books, so why should writers seek their services? The truth is that working with an agent is a risk-free investment for authors who want to be published traditionally. An agent’s primary concern is to improve a manuscript’s chances of being acquired by a publishing house. Agents work for authors by negotiating deals with publishing houses and receive a fixed return of 15 percent if the manuscript is acquired. Agents handle the business side of writing; a facet of publishing that bewilders many authors. They can decipher the legal and financial jargon in contracts so that authors can secure the best deal possible. Most importantly, agents are the most tangible form of human contact that many authors experience in the publishing industry. Authors often form long-lasting relationships with their literary agents.

Together, agents and writers share the ups and downs of publishing. In the midst of the publishing industry’s digital revolution, agents are more relevant than ever in helping writers get their voices heard.


Myth # 3: Self-publishing is just a fad

Those who are reluctant to embrace self-publishing and the digital revolution claim that these methods of publishing are fads that will soon be forgotten. Many consider e-publishing to be a bubble: quick to both rise and pop. Self-publishing is no ordinary bubble, however; it continues to swell and isn’t likely to pop anytime soon. In 2009, a little over 764,000 self-published books were produced while more than 288,000 titles were published traditionally, and the numbers continue to rise.

There are more options and tools than ever before for self-published authors every skill level. With services like Smashwords, Lulu, and CreateSpace, writers can produce, print, and distribute books from home, and more tools for self-published authors are constantly being developed. Companies like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Apple have all embraced the digital revolution as well by creating services for self-published authors and their readers. If other multimedia conglomerates and booksellers want to stay relevant and accommodate the millions of readers that use digital reading devices and support self-published writers, they must also follow suit. The question that publishers, authors, and readers must ask is not will digital self-publishing last, but how will we adapt to it.


Other references:


Literary Agents, bah! Who needs them?” by Jeff Rivera, MediaBistro
The self-epublishing bubble” by Ewan Morrison, The Guardian

Image courtesy of Lauren B Photography. Thanks, Lauren and Lincoln!


Lend us your type and trust, and we'll give you our minds.

~The Editors

Basic Book-Editing Services

Reader’s Reports


A reader’s report is the fastest, least expensive way to assess the state of one’s work. Whether it’s a short story, inspirational memoir, fictional novel, nonfiction book, old query letter, or new book proposal, we give the …

Query Letters


The material to include in your query letter is essential to snagging the attention of that agent or editor you’re gunning for. The relatively small real estate of a one-page query letter forces us to articulate our …

Book Proposals


A strong, well-structured book proposal significantly increases your chances of seeing your book through the editing process. Sometimes you don’t have to write an entire manuscript before submitting a proposal. In the case of many non-fiction and …



Many different walks of life have hired us to ghostwrite for them and, in each case, we’ve had varying degrees of involvement. Sometimes we’ve been hired to edit and clean up a rough draft, and other times …

Developmental Editing


Developmental editing more radically addresses the content of a work and can refer to any number of editorial landscapes: • Main premise • Plot structure • Character development • Overall organization • Writing style • Word choice • Dialogue And more. This kind of …



Copyediting requires attention to every word in a manuscript, a thorough knowledge of the style to be followed, and the ability to make quick, logical, and defensible decisions. This type of editing, sometimes referred to as line …



Proofreading is the last major stage of the editing process. As always, reading and consistent marking remain essential. When we proofread, we read word-for-word, noting all punctuation, paragraphing, capitalization, and italics, and ensure that any editing has …

Edited Titles News

Susie Pearl’s “Instructions” American Launch

US Cover_instructions[1]

As we’ve said before, of all the nonfiction authors we’ve worked with over the years, author and media guru Susie Pearl has one of the most buoyant, can-do attitudes we’ve ever had the pleasure of editing for. She’s always happy, and this vibrant character and experienced voice comes through in her writing. That’s …

Simons Foundation News


In addition to working with book publishers and individual authors, we also proofread and copyedit literature for quite a few nonprofits, including the Simons Foundation, a stellar science and mathematics organization whose mission is to advance the frontiers of research in mathematics and the basic sciences through generous grants and …

Impossible Loves: Essays by Erin McNellis


We are pleased to announce the recent publication of a book we both worked on earlier this year called Impossible Loves, a collection of essays by Erin McNellis, out this month in paperback from Paper Rock Tiger, an emerging press based out of Seattle. We copyedited the manuscript and handled the permissions for …

Instructions for Happiness and Success by Susie Pearl

bookseller front cover_web thumbnail blogpost

Of all the non-fiction authors we’ve worked with over the years, writer Susie Pearl has one of the most buoyant, can-do attitudes we’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. She’s always happy, and this is why we’re so over the moon about the recent news that her upcoming book …

Loving the Darcys

trouble w darcy

As anyone can tell, I work on a large number of Pride & Prejudice continuations. One of the authors whose novels I have the absolute pleasure of working on is Sharon Lathan. Her Darcy Saga series is growing all the time, and the most recent, volume 5, The Trouble with …

Jill Mansell News!

Staying at Daisy's

Jill Mansell is making some waves. Not only is her newest book, Staying at Daisy’s, fresh out in the US, but her novel Miranda’s Big Mistake is #12 on the New York Times ebook bestseller list and #86 on the USA Today bestseller list this week! I had the honor of proofreading the US edition of Miranda’s Big Mistake. I also got to do the proofreading for the US Staying at Daisy’s and the copyediting for the US edition of Take a Chance on Me, which won the Romance Novelists’ Association’s Pure Passion Romantic Comedy Prize! […]

Email: info (at) cogitatestudios (dot) com for more information.